Can Andy Burnham break out of Labour’s welfare trap?

Michael Dowsett, Director
18/11/2026

Yesterday saw the publication of the final report of Alan Milburn’s landmark review into youth unemployment, setting out plans to tackle Britain’s NEET crisis. At a press conference in central London, Milburn outlined a package of measures – including an overhaul of the benefits system for under-25s, additional employment support and changes to the skills system – in language that betrayed his roots as a New Labour Cabinet Minister, framed his recommendations as a recasting of the rights afforded to Britain’s young people and the obligations placed on them in an increasingly challenging labour market.

Andy Burnham’s government has warmly welcomed the broad thrust of the report. The question now is how far it will go in implementing Milburn’s key recommendations, given the fiscal and political challenges they pose. And the PM won’t have long to make up his mind. Speaking to the BBC earlier today, the Burnham said the Government’s direction of travel on both the Milburn review and Stephen Timms’s separate review of Personal Independence Payments (PIP) would become clear when it publishes the Ten Year Plan is published next month. A white paper reflecting the findings of both reviews will follow in the new year.

The fiscal challenge has been well rehearsed in recent weeks, ever since it became clear that Milburn was likely to recommend upfront funding to help young people into work, with savings due to take a decade to materialise. Finding that money without new tax rises will be no mean feat. Inflation (now at 3.6%) and plans for higher defence spending are already squeezing departmental budgets, before accounting for the cost of social care reform and the possibility that – despite the support announced at the Budget – households will need more help with energy bills when the price in the new year.

So far, criticism of plans to cut welfare support for some young people has been confined to Labour’s left flank. But once the Government publishes its impact assessment for the forthcoming legislation and campaigns get under way in individual constituencies, more Labour backbenchers could come under pressure to speak out.

Last summer’s rebellion against welfare cuts reflected wider discontent within the Parliamentary Labour Party over how Number 10 treated MPs and Keir Starmer’s political performance in his first year in office. Burnham is in a stronger position. His polling bounce is entering its fifth month, and Labour MPs have noticed a significant improvement in PLP engagement in recent months. The presence of key figures from last year’s rebellion at the top of his operation also improves his chances of carrying Labour MPs with him.

However, for all the challenges Burnham faces in selling welfare reform to his own party, the bigger test may lie in facing down a combination of opposition parties and shifting public opinion. Since the election, the Conservatives and Reform UK have seemed locked in a race to see who can promise the biggest welfare cuts. Public opinion, meanwhile, appears to have hardened as welfare spending has risen sharply since the pandemic and the tax burden needed to sustain it has grown.

At Prime Minister’s Questions today, Burnham’s responses to Kemi Badenoch pointed to a clear political strategy, seeking to chart a course between Labour backbenchers concerned about cuts and opposition parties calling for much deeper reductions in welfare spending. Burnham wants to present his post-Milburn agenda, which he has indicated could extend to older benefit claimants, as a pragmatic mix of changes to how support is provided and targeted measures to help people into work. His bet is that this approach can convince the median voter that they the more radical cuts offered by the Conservatives and Reform UK are an extreme response to an issue that is already being tackled.

If Burnham succeeds, the political and economic prize will be significant, particularly if he can point to tangible progress before the next election. Any easing of conflict in the Middle East following the US midterms, and delivery of the first phase of Milburn’s reforms, could set in motion a virtuous circle of fewer young people out of education, employment or training, higher employment and a lower welfare bill, providing a significant boost to the public finances.

Politically, Burnham has the opportunity to shake off Labour’s image as the ‘welfare party’ – a label that arguably dates back at least two decades – providing political space to tackle other long-standing policy challenges, such as social care reform. In doing so, Burnham could take the sting out of welfare as a campaign issue at the next election, denying the Conservatives and Reform a potent line of attack.

If he fails, patience among voters and Labour backbenchers may start to wear thin. Sluggish growth and longer-term changes in the economy, including the impact of AI on demand for younger workers, could keep NEET numbers stubbornly high. In this environment, the charge from the right that the Government has once again increased welfare spending without any tangible impact on worklessness would have a much better chance of sticking, and voter appetite for more radical measures would only grow.

We’ve cultivated an environment that harbours independence. Whether they are early birds who go to yoga and then smash their news updates before 8.30am, or they simply hate travelling on the tube in rush hour, we trust and respect our team’s skills and conscientiousness. As long as core responsibilities are covered, our team is free to work flexibly.

We’re proud to be a living wage employer. We believe that no one should have to choose between financial stability and doing a job they love, so we pay a wage that allows our team to save for a rainy day and guarantees a good quality of life.

Sign up to receive the Atticus Agenda


Sign Up Here

Many members of the Atticus Partners team hold the Communications Management Standard (CMS). CMS demonstrates a commitment to achieving excellence and assures our clients that we are providing the most effective service possible.